Vinnie's New York Chefs Pizzeria

Nestled in the heart of Cottonwood, AZ, Vinnie's New York Chefs Pizzeria stands out as a warm, inviting destination for families and pizza lovers craving an authentic Italian dining experience. This pizzeria and family restaurant effortlessly blends New York-style tradition with heartfelt hospitality, making each visit feel both comforting and exciting.

The moment you step inside Vinnie’s, the inviting aroma of freshly baked pizza and garlic-infused delights envelops you, setting the perfect stage for a truly satisfying meal. Their menu is a tribute to classic Italian favorites enhanced with a family-friendly twist. Whether you’re here for their famed Supreme Pizza loaded with vibrant toppings or the robust Spaghetti and Meatballs simmered in rich tomato sauce, each dish resonates with genuine flavor and care.

Start your meal with a basket of their Garlic Knots—hand-stretched, tied, and baked to golden perfection, seasoned with fragrant garlic, sesame seeds, and fresh parsley. They strike the perfect balance between savory and satisfyingly soft, leaving you eager for the next bite. If you’re feeling adventurous, the White Garlic Pizza offers a luscious white sauce topped with roasted garlic and melty mozzarella, while the Bacon & Cheddar pizza creates a comforting crescendo of smoky bacon hugged by creamy cheddar over mozzarella. Vegetarians will appreciate the thoughtfully crafted Spinach & Mushroom or Vegetable pizzas, both featuring vibrant greens and mushrooms atop a delicate spinach cream sauce.

The chicken selections, like the juicy Grilled Chicken Sandwich or the crispy yet tender Buffalo Chicken Sandwich with house-made bleu cheese dressing, deliver layers of flavor that complement the pizzas perfectly. And if you’re seeking fun, shareable appetizers such as crispy Mozzarella Sticks, indulgent Potato Skins, or the surprisingly addictive Fried Pickle Chips.

Beyond the food, Vinnie’s shines with attentive, friendly service that enhances the overall dining atmosphere. Customers frequently praise the clean, comfortable setting and the polite, helpful staff who make every guest feel like family. “My Philly cheesesteak was delicious, and the rest of my family was happy,” shares loyal visitor Doug Carter, capturing the sense of satisfaction many diners experience here.

Travelers and locals alike rave about the authenticity and quality. “Best Pizza I have ever had,” says Joseph Myers, emphasizing the spot's reputation among pizza aficionados seeking genuine New York-style flavors far from the city’s hustle. And with continuous improvements under new ownership, Vinnie’s reputation grows steadily, charming return guests who delight in the evolving menu and consistent quality.

For those looking for a casual yet memorable meal where traditional recipes meet earnest craftsmanship and a welcoming vibe, Vinnie’s New York Chefs Pizzeria is an outstanding choice. Whether grabbing a quick slice or indulging in a full family dinner, expect to leave with the comfort of hearty flavors and the warmth of genuine hospitality.

Location: 516 East, AZ-89A Ste. 101, Cottonwood, AZ 86326

Phone: +1 928-646-3333